San Francisco Considers Stricter Rules on Nuisance Evictions

San Francisco Considers Stricter Rules on Nuisance Evictions
Photo Credit: Unsplash.com

San Francisco considers stricter rules on nuisance evictions following a 41% increase in related notices filed with the city’s Rent Board. A proposal introduced by Supervisor Myrna Melgar would establish stricter standards for certain eviction complaints, address property damage disputes and extend deadlines for wrongful-eviction lawsuits. The changes remain under consideration.

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors’ Land Use and Transportation Committee scheduled a hearing on the proposal for November 16, 2026, placing the city’s nuisance eviction standards under review as rental housing costs remain elevated.

The ordinance, identified as File 261104, would change the circumstances under which landlords can seek to remove tenants for nuisance-related conduct. It would also address situations in which tenants have been permitted to pay for property damage.

As of the latest available legislative record, the measure had not received final approval.

Key Takeaways

  • San Francisco recorded 405 nuisance eviction notices between March 2025 and February 2026, a 41% increase from the previous reporting period
  • Supervisor Myrna Melgar introduced legislation to clarify and tighten the requirements for nuisance-based evictions
  • The proposal would restrict certain property damage evictions and extend the deadline for wrongful-eviction lawsuits to three years
  • The ordinance was scheduled for committee review on November 16, 2026, and had not been enacted in the latest available record

San Francisco Considers Stricter Rules on Nuisance Evictions After 41% Rise

The San Francisco Rent Board recorded 405 nuisance eviction notices from March 1, 2025, through February 28, 2026. That compares with 288 notices during the preceding 12-month period, representing a 41% increase.

Overall, the agency recorded 1,488 eviction notices during the newer reporting period, compared with 1,033 previously. The figures cover notices submitted to the Rent Board and do not establish how many households were ultimately removed.

City records distinguish between an eviction notice and a completed eviction. Some disputes are resolved before reaching court, while others proceed through legal channels. Certain nonpayment notices are also not required to be filed with the agency, limiting the completeness of citywide totals.

The increase comes amid broader concerns about the cost of remaining in San Francisco. Mayor Daniel Lurie declared a San Francisco rent emergency in September 2026, accompanied by proposals addressing rental costs, tenant protections and legal assistance.

Melgar has questioned whether the rise in nuisance complaints reflects a comparable increase in disruptive tenant behavior. She has also identified higher market rents as a potential factor influencing disputes involving long-term tenants.

However, the Rent Board figures do not establish why individual notices were issued or whether the underlying allegations were justified.

Proposed Changes Would Raise the Legal Threshold for Evictions

San Francisco’s existing Rent Ordinance permits certain evictions when tenants commit or allow conduct classified as a nuisance. Current language covers behavior that is severe, continuing or recurring and substantially interferes with the comfort, safety or enjoyment of landlords or other building residents.

The proposed amendment would narrow those standards.

Under the revised language, conduct would generally need to be severe or both continuing and recurring to qualify under the nuisance provision. The proposed definition would also place greater emphasis on conduct affecting other occupants.

Melgar described the objective of the measure as an effort “to tighten up the definition of nuisance” when discussing the legislation in October.

The proposal does not eliminate nuisance evictions. Landlords would retain the ability to pursue cases involving qualifying conduct, including serious property damage, unlawful uses of rental units and substantial disturbances, where the applicable legal requirements are met.

Another provision would restrict property damage evictions when landlords have allowed tenants to pay for the damage. The proposal also seeks to extend the filing period for certain wrongful-eviction lawsuits to three years, subject to specified exceptions.

The changes could affect how property owners document complaints and how courts evaluate disputed conduct. They would not automatically invalidate existing notices or establish that every nuisance allegation involves misconduct by a landlord.

Nob Hill Tenant Dispute Highlights the Stakes for Property Owners

The legislation followed a dispute involving residents of 1120 Jackson Street, a 16-unit apartment building near Chinatown and Nob Hill.

Six households received eviction notices after the building changed ownership in 2025. Residents challenged allegations involving clutter, cleanliness and conditions inside their apartments. Several affected tenants had lived in the building for decades.

The residents formed a tenants association and sought assistance from housing advocates. Their representatives questioned whether the complaints justified removal and raised concerns about communication between management and residents.

The property owner, Nabob Hill LLC, disputed that characterization. Its attorney, Daniel Bornstein, said the owners had provided repeated notices concerning alleged safety and cleanliness problems.

“The owners have extended numerous courtesy notices to the tenants,” Bornstein stated in a June response concerning the dispute.

The competing accounts illustrate why documentation, notice requirements and the severity of alleged conduct can become central issues in eviction proceedings. The allegations do not establish wrongdoing by either party, and their legal merits depend on the evidence presented.

For tenants, an eviction dispute can create uncertainty about remaining in an established home. Finding replacement accommodation may also involve substantially different rental costs. Some residents have explored lower-cost housing alternatives, although shared accommodation differs significantly from conventional long-term housing.

For landlords, maintaining safe living conditions and responding to complaints from neighboring tenants remain important responsibilities. The proposed rules would require closer consideration of whether alleged conduct meets the applicable nuisance standard.

The November 16 committee agenda included the ordinance, with Melgar, Danny Sauter, Jackie Fielder and Chyanne Chen listed as sponsors in the city’s legislative record.

The publicly available record did not confirm final passage or an enactment date. Until the required approval process is completed, San Francisco’s existing nuisance eviction provisions remain in effect.

Frequently Asked Questions

What changes are proposed for nuisance evictions in San Francisco?

San Francisco considers stricter rules on nuisance evictions that would narrow qualifying conduct, restrict certain property damage evictions and extend the period for filing wrongful-eviction claims. The proposed changes have not been enacted.

How much have nuisance eviction notices increased?

The San Francisco Rent Board recorded 405 nuisance eviction notices between March 2025 and February 2026, compared with 288 during the previous reporting period. That represents an increase of approximately 41%.

Would the proposal prevent landlords from evicting disruptive tenants?

No. The ordinance would retain nuisance as a possible legal ground for eviction while tightening the requirements for qualifying conduct. Landlords would still need to meet applicable legal standards.

Has San Francisco approved the new nuisance eviction rules?

The ordinance was scheduled for review by the Land Use and Transportation Committee on November 16, 2026. The latest available legislative record did not confirm final approval or enactment.

San Francisco Post

Chronicles of the Bay Area’s heartbeat.